Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Emma Price's avatar

Both men and women were raised by parents who, whatever their “religion” (including atheism, nothing in particular etc), probably raised their sons and daughters the same way. But when the children got to school, they were endlessly taught that men oppress women and liberalism is the answer. So naturally the girls become political liberals and the boys conservative. Their own religion then follows.

I think this gap may continue to grow as long as the educational system is so dominated by liberals.

Richard Plotzker's avatar

So if I understand the data correctly, if your church looks like my synagogue, where everyone is on Medicare, and your Future Planning Committee needs to restore its pipeline, they should recruit coeds majoring in psych at a campus MAGA event?

FIRE data has a lot of respondents, which has pluses and minuses. Since the organization has an agenda, I wonder how representative those N=68K really are of the sample of young people. My alma mater and Ryan's current university are each a big multiple of 4% Jewish, with each getting an F on the sponsor's preferred responses to their survey.

Big sampling tends to magnify small differences as significant, which Ryan does well to discount, though with a sample of 68K, a two percentage point difference may be P<0.05 when calculated. More importantly, sampling needs to be representative of the rest of the population that is not sampled. So a biopsy gets just few cells but they are representative enough to reach a conclusion. Taking universities where the sponsor intends to laud some and vilify others, with a good presampling notion of which campuses are which, may not reflect what young adults think irrespective of the large number surveyed.

9 more comments...

Ready for more?