Both men and women were raised by parents who, whatever their “religion” (including atheism, nothing in particular etc), probably raised their sons and daughters the same way. But when the children got to school, they were endlessly taught that men oppress women and liberalism is the answer. So naturally the girls become political liberals and the boys conservative. Their own religion then follows.
I think this gap may continue to grow as long as the educational system is so dominated by liberals.
Political orientation is, in many ways, brain structure. Conservatives have a larger fear center, the amygdala. The education system isn't doing this to college kids, college kids (or at least young women) are evolving away from brain structures supportive of conservative and religious belief systems. A quick web search will confirm with the keywords "brain structure religious political beliefs." I can provide a list of DOIs of peer reviewed literature upon request.
This is also why religious belief is declining by about half generation over generation, imho. It is evolution.
(doing my best to avoid breaking this substack's rules while surfacing facts, data, and evidence as it relates to how biology, politics, and religion are all intertwined)
I’d be curious about those articles, if you could post them that would be great. I’m also curious about how what you said connects to liberal women having greater rates of anxiety/depression, and also the conservative birthrate being greater than the liberal birthrate (although that’s only a recent trend in the last 20-30 years).
Kosinski, M., Khambatta, P., & Wang, Y. (2024). Facial recognition technology and human raters can predict political orientation from images of expressionless faces even when controlling for demographics and self-presentation. American Psychologist, 79(7), 942–955. https://doi.org/10.1037/amp0001295
Rasmussen SHR, Ludeke SG, Klemmensen R. Using deep learning to predict ideology from facial photographs: expressions, beauty, and extra-facial information. Sci Rep. 2023 Mar 31;13(1):5257. doi: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-023-31796-1 PMID: 37002240; PMCID: PMC10066183.
Pedersen WS, Muftuler LT, Larson CL. Conservatism and the neural circuitry of threat: economic conservatism predicts greater amygdala-BNST connectivity during periods of threat vs safety. Soc Cogn Affect Neurosci. 2018 Jan 1;13(1):43-51. doi: https://doi.org/10.1093/scan/nsx133 PMID: 29126127; PMCID: PMC5793824.
Haas, I.J., Baker, M.N. & Gonzalez, F.J. Who Can Deviate from the Party Line? Political Ideology Moderates Evaluation of Incongruent Policy Positions in Insula and Anterior Cingulate Cortex. Soc Just Res 30, 355–380 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11211-017-0295-0
Kanai R, Feilden T, Firth C ... Political Orientations Are Correlated with Brain Structure in Young Adults Current Biology, 2011; 21, 677-680 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2011.03.017
(facial structure and brain structure are related, which I why I included references regarding the ability to obtain signal from facial structure as it relates to politics and ideology)
With regards to conservative birth rates, best I can come up with is that conservative belief systems center more around faith versus data, so conservatives are less likely to critically think about having kids versus more liberal mindsets. They have kids because they believe they are supposed, and not questioning this life path as much as others. Religion is a factor from a peer and social pressure perspective; you're more likely to have kids if your peers are, as fertility is mimetic (governance.fyi covers this in pretty good detail as a pro-natalist publication imho). Go to church often? Your fertility rate is likely to be higher, regardless of how much you believe (Ryan can correct me if I'm wrong here, but this is what I've taken from his survey reporting in this regard).
With regards to greater levels of anxiety and depression, I attribute this to more awareness and understanding versus those who operate at, for lack of a more polite term, other levels of functioning. "To know and understand is to suffer."
Surveys tend not to differentiate by year but I’ve never agreed with this. If it was accurate you would expect freshmen to be more conservative than seniors and there’s no evidence that’s correct. I think teenager daughters are socialized not to disagree with their parents on political issues so parents think they agree their conservative beliefs when they never did. I suspect a survey of high school students would have the same trends.
Can you let me know where this happened? I asked my wife (who is more educated and smarter than me in general, MS vs BS), and said this never happened to her, and I know I didn't see it as a guy.
So if I understand the data correctly, if your church looks like my synagogue, where everyone is on Medicare, and your Future Planning Committee needs to restore its pipeline, they should recruit coeds majoring in psych at a campus MAGA event?
FIRE data has a lot of respondents, which has pluses and minuses. Since the organization has an agenda, I wonder how representative those N=68K really are of the sample of young people. My alma mater and Ryan's current university are each a big multiple of 4% Jewish, with each getting an F on the sponsor's preferred responses to their survey.
Big sampling tends to magnify small differences as significant, which Ryan does well to discount, though with a sample of 68K, a two percentage point difference may be P<0.05 when calculated. More importantly, sampling needs to be representative of the rest of the population that is not sampled. So a biopsy gets just few cells but they are representative enough to reach a conclusion. Taking universities where the sponsor intends to laud some and vilify others, with a good presampling notion of which campuses are which, may not reflect what young adults think irrespective of the large number surveyed.
"the political gap on campuses between men and women is absolutely huge and it’s going to cause all kinds of problems going forward, especially when it comes to partnering and fertility."
I predict that the above quote is going to make the rounds on the internet! Very compelling.
But does it depict the evolving political dichotomy in the broader Generation Z? My question is rhetorical, as the post clearly states that the "political gap" is among university students. But this fact causes me to wonder about that same gap among the Generation Z cohort who are not enrolled in secondary education.
I know two Generation Z men who "imported" wives from the Philippines. They are lovely young ladies and, by American standards, conservative. Is this a coincidence? Makes me wonder.
I wonder whether underlying this trend is the increased attention during the past decade to masculinity and male roles. The women's movement has led over the past several generations to more attention to their status and expanded opportunities in most realms (even if full equivalence has remained elusive). In consequence, men and their opportunities have been neglected. Now, the pushback, amplifed by the Trump era, has begun. Men become more drawn to conservatism, in part, perhaps, because of its affinity with traditional gender roles. Religion and church-going may function, to some extent, at least, in a similar way.
It will be fascinating to find out if there's enough collatable data to be able to answer that final question. My instinct is that it's very much the former (people's politics moving to the left tends to make it more likely that they deconstruct their faith) but I'm aware I live in a liberal media bubble.
When I look at the first graph it appears that the genders in most of the religous traditions are pretty close. Does this suggest that college attendees are 50% male and 50% female? I thought that the numbers I read in the papers are quite different.
Both men and women were raised by parents who, whatever their “religion” (including atheism, nothing in particular etc), probably raised their sons and daughters the same way. But when the children got to school, they were endlessly taught that men oppress women and liberalism is the answer. So naturally the girls become political liberals and the boys conservative. Their own religion then follows.
I think this gap may continue to grow as long as the educational system is so dominated by liberals.
Political orientation is, in many ways, brain structure. Conservatives have a larger fear center, the amygdala. The education system isn't doing this to college kids, college kids (or at least young women) are evolving away from brain structures supportive of conservative and religious belief systems. A quick web search will confirm with the keywords "brain structure religious political beliefs." I can provide a list of DOIs of peer reviewed literature upon request.
This is also why religious belief is declining by about half generation over generation, imho. It is evolution.
(doing my best to avoid breaking this substack's rules while surfacing facts, data, and evidence as it relates to how biology, politics, and religion are all intertwined)
I’d be curious about those articles, if you could post them that would be great. I’m also curious about how what you said connects to liberal women having greater rates of anxiety/depression, and also the conservative birthrate being greater than the liberal birthrate (although that’s only a recent trend in the last 20-30 years).
Kosinski, M., Khambatta, P., & Wang, Y. (2024). Facial recognition technology and human raters can predict political orientation from images of expressionless faces even when controlling for demographics and self-presentation. American Psychologist, 79(7), 942–955. https://doi.org/10.1037/amp0001295
Rasmussen SHR, Ludeke SG, Klemmensen R. Using deep learning to predict ideology from facial photographs: expressions, beauty, and extra-facial information. Sci Rep. 2023 Mar 31;13(1):5257. doi: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-023-31796-1 PMID: 37002240; PMCID: PMC10066183.
Pedersen WS, Muftuler LT, Larson CL. Conservatism and the neural circuitry of threat: economic conservatism predicts greater amygdala-BNST connectivity during periods of threat vs safety. Soc Cogn Affect Neurosci. 2018 Jan 1;13(1):43-51. doi: https://doi.org/10.1093/scan/nsx133 PMID: 29126127; PMCID: PMC5793824.
Haas, I.J., Baker, M.N. & Gonzalez, F.J. Who Can Deviate from the Party Line? Political Ideology Moderates Evaluation of Incongruent Policy Positions in Insula and Anterior Cingulate Cortex. Soc Just Res 30, 355–380 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11211-017-0295-0
Kanai R, Feilden T, Firth C ... Political Orientations Are Correlated with Brain Structure in Young Adults Current Biology, 2011; 21, 677-680 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2011.03.017
(facial structure and brain structure are related, which I why I included references regarding the ability to obtain signal from facial structure as it relates to politics and ideology)
With regards to conservative birth rates, best I can come up with is that conservative belief systems center more around faith versus data, so conservatives are less likely to critically think about having kids versus more liberal mindsets. They have kids because they believe they are supposed, and not questioning this life path as much as others. Religion is a factor from a peer and social pressure perspective; you're more likely to have kids if your peers are, as fertility is mimetic (governance.fyi covers this in pretty good detail as a pro-natalist publication imho). Go to church often? Your fertility rate is likely to be higher, regardless of how much you believe (Ryan can correct me if I'm wrong here, but this is what I've taken from his survey reporting in this regard).
With regards to greater levels of anxiety and depression, I attribute this to more awareness and understanding versus those who operate at, for lack of a more polite term, other levels of functioning. "To know and understand is to suffer."
Surveys tend not to differentiate by year but I’ve never agreed with this. If it was accurate you would expect freshmen to be more conservative than seniors and there’s no evidence that’s correct. I think teenager daughters are socialized not to disagree with their parents on political issues so parents think they agree their conservative beliefs when they never did. I suspect a survey of high school students would have the same trends.
Can you let me know where this happened? I asked my wife (who is more educated and smarter than me in general, MS vs BS), and said this never happened to her, and I know I didn't see it as a guy.
So if I understand the data correctly, if your church looks like my synagogue, where everyone is on Medicare, and your Future Planning Committee needs to restore its pipeline, they should recruit coeds majoring in psych at a campus MAGA event?
FIRE data has a lot of respondents, which has pluses and minuses. Since the organization has an agenda, I wonder how representative those N=68K really are of the sample of young people. My alma mater and Ryan's current university are each a big multiple of 4% Jewish, with each getting an F on the sponsor's preferred responses to their survey.
Big sampling tends to magnify small differences as significant, which Ryan does well to discount, though with a sample of 68K, a two percentage point difference may be P<0.05 when calculated. More importantly, sampling needs to be representative of the rest of the population that is not sampled. So a biopsy gets just few cells but they are representative enough to reach a conclusion. Taking universities where the sponsor intends to laud some and vilify others, with a good presampling notion of which campuses are which, may not reflect what young adults think irrespective of the large number surveyed.
"the political gap on campuses between men and women is absolutely huge and it’s going to cause all kinds of problems going forward, especially when it comes to partnering and fertility."
I predict that the above quote is going to make the rounds on the internet! Very compelling.
But does it depict the evolving political dichotomy in the broader Generation Z? My question is rhetorical, as the post clearly states that the "political gap" is among university students. But this fact causes me to wonder about that same gap among the Generation Z cohort who are not enrolled in secondary education.
I know two Generation Z men who "imported" wives from the Philippines. They are lovely young ladies and, by American standards, conservative. Is this a coincidence? Makes me wonder.
I wonder whether underlying this trend is the increased attention during the past decade to masculinity and male roles. The women's movement has led over the past several generations to more attention to their status and expanded opportunities in most realms (even if full equivalence has remained elusive). In consequence, men and their opportunities have been neglected. Now, the pushback, amplifed by the Trump era, has begun. Men become more drawn to conservatism, in part, perhaps, because of its affinity with traditional gender roles. Religion and church-going may function, to some extent, at least, in a similar way.
It will be fascinating to find out if there's enough collatable data to be able to answer that final question. My instinct is that it's very much the former (people's politics moving to the left tends to make it more likely that they deconstruct their faith) but I'm aware I live in a liberal media bubble.
When I look at the first graph it appears that the genders in most of the religous traditions are pretty close. Does this suggest that college attendees are 50% male and 50% female? I thought that the numbers I read in the papers are quite different.