Speaking as a Catholic, yes we're certainly not "people of the book".
If you hold a Catholic pastor or theologian's feet to the fire, he would have to admit that in Catholic doctrine, it is not strictly necessary for non-clergy to spend ANY time personally reading Scripture — I mean, necessary for one's salvation and sanctification. It's obviously encouraged by the Church nowadays, but only since around the 1890s; there hasn't been as much time for it to permeate Catholic culture.
And personal Scripture reading won't ever occupy quite the same space in a Catholic's heart or mind as it does for a Protestant's because for a Catholic, it's one activity among many that fall under the broader heading of private _devotional_ time.
Ask a Protestant about how much time they spend each week in personal devotions, and the question is practically equivalent to asking how much time they spend reading / studying / meditating on the Bible on their own. But to put the same kind of question fairly to a Catholic, you'd have to ask how much time or how frequently each week they read the Bible OR pray the Rosary OR read some book on the lives of the saints or a Life of Christ or… you get the idea. Because in the minds of most Catholics, all of those activities and more "count" in the same way as "stuff I do by myself to try to get closer to God" i.e. private devotion.
You could say that Catholics may perceive it as "devotion gap" with Protestants, in which we both use Scripture a ton in our public worship, but the big bushy tree of private devotion has been pruned down to only one branch.
Here's what I've always found super interesting about the two traditions.
Catholics, on average, read WAY more scripture during corporate worship than their Protestant counterparts. I mean, four separate readings every single time. I've been in hundreds of evangelical worship services where less than 4 verses were read in total.
But then Catholics barely touch the Bible outside of worship while evangelicals are nearly obsessed with it.
I’m Catholic and attend weekly. I’d say the Bible is extremely important but I think I read it once last month. I go to adoration twice a week (prayer before the blessed sacrament) pray the rosary 2-3 times a week, plus attend daily mass once a week. I do tend to do more spiritual reading than read the Bible.
My two cents is we just spend our devotional time in other ways. It would be interesting to see a graph of how much time different denominations spend on devotions outside of Sunday attendance. I bet it would be way closer.
Your response is fascinating to me. You're obviously very religious and devoted to your faith, but in a way (and speaking kindly) you're a different species than an evangelical. Meant to be funny, not offensive. :)
Ash, our Parish has signed up for the Reach More program and embraced a vision of “go out in the community to make disciples” … I think it may be more accurate to restate as follows: “Make disciples of Jesus Christ and invite them into the fullness of the Catholic faith.” I assume the other denominations might consider a similar strategy.
My husband was raised in an Evangelical church, and I in the United Methodist church. After we converted to Catholicism, my husband mentioned to our priest that he and I had just embarked on a Bible-in-a-year reading project, since we had additional books of the Bible in our Catholic Bibles now. Our priest was legit confused: We were doing what now? Systematically reading the Bible every single day so that nothing was missed? You know, he said, you could also read the lectionary readings for every day and over the course of three years that would pretty much do the same thing.
Anyway, thought I'd share this anecdote. Gotta run now, though, because I'm behind on my daily readings and Sirach isn't gonna read itself. But I got my daily Ryan Burge reading in, which should count for something.
I hear you on that one but the lectionary repeats itself every three years, same scripture readings, leaving the rest of the bible out. Also verses are taken out of context. People really need to read the whole gospel/epistle/ etc to get the overall meaning of the book.
Agree. Reading, for instance, all the Psalms in order shows that "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?" that Jesus cries out on the cross is the first line of a song that ends in triumph, and that is followed by "The Lord's my shepherd." Reading all of Song of Songs in one sitting shows that it is, indeed, a song with a pretty chiasmatic structure.
Having verses in isolation is fine, and I'm a big fan of memorizing individual verses from Scripture. But it's not the same as reading everything in context.
By your definition, I am an evangelical although I wrestle with that term. But it is interesting to me what you have discovered in your research, viz. how little devout Catholics (and others) read their Bibles. This is odd to me, because that is the central practice of my Christian faith.
I am not writing to draw attention to myself, but perhaps to exhibit myself as a typical evangelical. Many years ago I adopted a Bible-reading methodology based on Billy Graham's daily practice: Starting in Genesis and Matthew, I read four chapters of the OT and four chapters of the NT (I omit the daily 7 chapters of Psalms as Billy Graham did, I read Psalms in the course of reading). The next day I resume where I left off. And I enjoy reading different versions (except the old King James!). By this method, I read the Bible more than twice through a year. It's fascinating and I learn so much. And I frequent compare verses between different versions, very illuminating. And I am not unique in my church world.
I guess that is why I am dumbfounded when I meet Christians who rarely read their Bibles and have never read it through completely, or only once as some form of box checking ("I did it, I read the Bible all the way through!" type of thing).
If I am a typical evangelical, then this helps to explain the head-shaking that many evangelicals might hold toward, say, Catholics, who are less interested in their Bibles. I have a very devout Catholic friend and we can talk frankly of such things and he simply is not interested in reading the Bible and if he does, it's maybe once a week (I know, a sample of one).
Great post. It exposes the way different Christian denominations (groups) approach the Bible. I guess that is why, in part, my Catholic friend cannot get his head around sola scriptura. :)
Not a Catholic, but it would not surprise me if many Catholics consider the lectionary readings spiritually equivalent to reading the bible. For most of Christian history the average parishioner was either illiterate or didn't have the funds to purchase a bible, so the mass would have been the only realistic access to the scriptures.
This is anecdotal, but I have noticed that the typical evangelical sermon will do a very deep dive on a single scripture, most often from John or Paul's letters, while the average Cathodox service includes a handful of read scriptures from the Psalms, Gospels, epistles, prophets, etc.
Ryan, as a Catholic, I thought, "but wouldn't everyone be doing the lectionary reading, because that's literally reading Scripture, so that adds up to reading the Bible >1x per week....?"
Others have also noted private devotions, like praying Rosary prayers. But this is literally reciting Scripture (Luke 1:26, 42). Do Scripture recitations not count?
I personally think it counts, though I'm not sure how to best get at these kinds of questions on surveys. Undoubtedly the language of religion surveys in the US is a mix of Protestant-coded and secular-coded, probably to ensure a higher completion rate.
In my (mainline) church on a typical Sunday, if I threw a stone at a random pew, it is very likely to hit someone who does not know what the words "lectionary" or "liturgy" mean. But we want those folks participating in these surveys, which unfortunately means using simpler language and more black-and-white questions.
Insightful response. Your thoughts remind me that it is important for believers to understand that the NT was written in Koine Greek, the Greek of the common people, not some scholarly or "academic" form available only to priests and the educated, but meant to be accessible to the regular guy or gal.
I think it would be worth evaluating within Catholics those who grew up in a pre-Vatican II experience vs. a post-Vatican II experience. Is there a change in Bible usage by Roman Catholics along generational lines once the Magisterium opened up Mass and Scripture reading to the vernacular languages?
The people who grew up pre-V2 are over 80 at this point and thus mostly on their way to their eternal reward. The vast majority of current respondents will have grown up post-V2.
Would have been interesting to add the Jews to the mix, as our relation to Hebrew Bible seems quite different, though we have a wide spectrum of attendance at worship. Torah is central to the religion, liturgy is dominated by copy & paste from Biblical sources, so centrality has a high consensus. And Torah plus a section of Prophets is read publicly weekly as part of worship. Self-study seems a little different. It happens widely, across denominations, but we tend not to take the Old Testament that we all got as Bar Mitzvah gifts off the shelf and read from it. What we do instead is seek out commentaries by rabbis or other scholars who have already digested a section of the weekly portion to which they share their insights. It's more like reading op-eds than Cliff Notes, but it's also not reading a primary source that we will hear verbally and follow along in the Books, either in Hebrew or translation, as the reader chants each section.
How well that correlates with attendance is hard to guess. Much of this exposure is passive, the public reading and the rabbi's comments at worship, though many synagogues have classes where the weekly portion is discussed with questions offered to those who attend them. Individual study, likely minimal.
It has always puzzled me why Jews would read the "op-eds" (rabbinic commentaries) more than the primary source. Could you expound on this and explain or guess why this is?
Lots of reasons. First, we do not ignore the primary sources, which are read each Saturday and which they have as part of our religious school curriculum. But for individual ongoing study, the commentaries are much greater in volume, in their spectrum of ideas, and merge better with other parts of education. Our teachers assing us novels and history texts, but our required papers and exams test our interpretations of what we have read. Jewish mental function, embedded in our liturgy, is divided into three parts: da-at or core knowledge, binah or insight, and saichel or good judment. The ability to function this way depends on creating our own opinions of a primary source and appreciating the insights of those who have accumulated greater wisdom. So the commentaries are what we mostly use as learning resources.
It could be because there is no "primary source" as the books in the various bibles are all interpreted, and those interpretations are different depending on a lot of factors. Just my two cents as they say.
But you still have to interpret the interpretations. So does that mean there is no "secondary source" either?
Catholics talk about how the magisterium helps them interpret the Bible... but then talk to 10 Catholics about what the magisterium means and I find there is 12 interpretations of the magisterium's interpretation of the Bible. We just can't get away from interpretation.
As a mainline Protestant pastor CC (DOC) I would guess most of our members fall toward the Catholic bible ownership pattern (family bible, Bible given at baptism, etc) despite us saying we are “people of the book” and “we take the bible seriously, not literally).
I try my best to respect different traditions and their practices. What sends me into high irritation is an Evangelical Protestant who thinks he is refuting Islam by proof texting passages from the Koran.
I wonder if there might also be a some devotions that Catholics might not count as Bible reading that arguably should. For example, some Catholics read/study the readings for the upcoming Sunday ahead of time. It's something that's highly encouraged at a Newman Center near where I live, and there are groups that meet weekly to discuss the readings. But because those readings are often collected in specialized books like missals or on dedicated websites, I don't think many Catholics would naturally call that "reading the Bible", despite the fact that they're meditating on Scripture.
Two experiences that tie in with the idea that our faiths are oriented in a different manner:
1) As a born and raised Evangelical, it wasn't until I started dating a Catholic that I realized how much scripture they get in their worship services. Perhaps some of the lower individual reading rates is because communal reading holds a greater priority in liturgical traditions.
2) I also didn't appreciate how much church history mattered to Catholics until I attended and event called Theology on Tap with my Catholic friends in university. The speakers cited saints and popes the way that Evangelical speakers cite Bible passages, building arguments from and proof-texting their arguments based on them.
I've come to appreciate the value of communal scripture reading and understanding church history through these and other experiences, even though I still get a lot from my individual study of scripture.
Glad I’m not the only Catholic kid who received a Bible from his Grandma for his First Communion. I still have it to this day, but I can’t say I’ve ever read out of it. As a family we had one BIG Bible that sat on our fire place mantle my entire childhood, that also never got pulled down and read out of.
I’ll give a brief defense of Catholics. I think that as other posters have noted Catholics do other things in their “personal time” with the Lord that Protestants don’t do, so it probably isn’t a totally fair metric. For instance, my Catholic aunts and uncles I would consider to be very much prayer warriors in the sense that I know they spend very much time in personal devotion and prayer-but I don’t honestly think they’ve ever really read through the Bible. I know when I talk to them about Christianity it doesn’t seem like they know it like I have come to know it.
That said, I know that when I converted to evangelicalism as an adult and actually read through the whole Bible for the first time, I actually remember being quite sad just about how little I actually knew about my Christian faith and its history before that endeavor. Reading through the Word has been a huge gift to me and I’ve attempted to tell my Catholic family and friends about how good it is to do, there just isn’t much interest.
It would be interesting to know how many folk read the Old Testament together with the New, or, if you will, how many believe that the Bible is, really, just the New Testament, as the Old was superseded by Christ.
Catholics are much less interested in reading the Bible than Evangelicals. This might explain why Catholics are better at gaining institutional power. There are plenty of Catholic academics, but few Evangelicals.
We had a family Bible and maybe a spare. We had two editions of 'Lives of the Saints', but one was grandma's and in German. Individually, we each had a Missal and a rosary.
Thanks Ryan this is good stuff. I'd like to see you do something with the role of 'Tradition" and 'tradition' between Roman Catholics and Protestants. RCs as I understand it, have seen the T as an equal partner with 'reading the Bible' for making disciples.
Ryan, your data raise an important question: What are the implications of these different postures toward Scripture for the shared mission of Catholics and evangelicals?
Both traditions are called to make disciples, yet they approach that mission from substantially different perspectives. Using a military metaphor, it is difficult for allies to win a war when they cannot agree on the mission or how best to accomplish it.
Perhaps the greater danger is not that Christians disagree, but that our differences become so important that we lose sight of the mission we share. Division can become a weakness that is exploited—and we can then rationalize our separate positions rather than honestly asking whether our approach is producing the results Christ commanded.
I explored this question in Christian Unity: Can We Disagree Without Dividing? The central question is simple: Can Christians with important theological differences work together to fulfill the Great Commission?
Speaking as a Catholic, yes we're certainly not "people of the book".
If you hold a Catholic pastor or theologian's feet to the fire, he would have to admit that in Catholic doctrine, it is not strictly necessary for non-clergy to spend ANY time personally reading Scripture — I mean, necessary for one's salvation and sanctification. It's obviously encouraged by the Church nowadays, but only since around the 1890s; there hasn't been as much time for it to permeate Catholic culture.
And personal Scripture reading won't ever occupy quite the same space in a Catholic's heart or mind as it does for a Protestant's because for a Catholic, it's one activity among many that fall under the broader heading of private _devotional_ time.
Ask a Protestant about how much time they spend each week in personal devotions, and the question is practically equivalent to asking how much time they spend reading / studying / meditating on the Bible on their own. But to put the same kind of question fairly to a Catholic, you'd have to ask how much time or how frequently each week they read the Bible OR pray the Rosary OR read some book on the lives of the saints or a Life of Christ or… you get the idea. Because in the minds of most Catholics, all of those activities and more "count" in the same way as "stuff I do by myself to try to get closer to God" i.e. private devotion.
You could say that Catholics may perceive it as "devotion gap" with Protestants, in which we both use Scripture a ton in our public worship, but the big bushy tree of private devotion has been pruned down to only one branch.
Here's what I've always found super interesting about the two traditions.
Catholics, on average, read WAY more scripture during corporate worship than their Protestant counterparts. I mean, four separate readings every single time. I've been in hundreds of evangelical worship services where less than 4 verses were read in total.
But then Catholics barely touch the Bible outside of worship while evangelicals are nearly obsessed with it.
It's fascinating.
True story. Episcopalians are the same. We get 4 readings every service. Sometimes an extra tossed in to make a point.
Peace be with you.
And also with you!
Or:
And with your spirit!
And also with you.
I wonder if the Catholic respondents include reading the daily mass readings or the liturgy of the hours as reading the Bible or not.
I’m Catholic and attend weekly. I’d say the Bible is extremely important but I think I read it once last month. I go to adoration twice a week (prayer before the blessed sacrament) pray the rosary 2-3 times a week, plus attend daily mass once a week. I do tend to do more spiritual reading than read the Bible.
My two cents is we just spend our devotional time in other ways. It would be interesting to see a graph of how much time different denominations spend on devotions outside of Sunday attendance. I bet it would be way closer.
Your response is fascinating to me. You're obviously very religious and devoted to your faith, but in a way (and speaking kindly) you're a different species than an evangelical. Meant to be funny, not offensive. :)
Ash, our Parish has signed up for the Reach More program and embraced a vision of “go out in the community to make disciples” … I think it may be more accurate to restate as follows: “Make disciples of Jesus Christ and invite them into the fullness of the Catholic faith.” I assume the other denominations might consider a similar strategy.
https://evangelicalcatholic.org/reachmore/
My husband was raised in an Evangelical church, and I in the United Methodist church. After we converted to Catholicism, my husband mentioned to our priest that he and I had just embarked on a Bible-in-a-year reading project, since we had additional books of the Bible in our Catholic Bibles now. Our priest was legit confused: We were doing what now? Systematically reading the Bible every single day so that nothing was missed? You know, he said, you could also read the lectionary readings for every day and over the course of three years that would pretty much do the same thing.
Anyway, thought I'd share this anecdote. Gotta run now, though, because I'm behind on my daily readings and Sirach isn't gonna read itself. But I got my daily Ryan Burge reading in, which should count for something.
I hear you on that one but the lectionary repeats itself every three years, same scripture readings, leaving the rest of the bible out. Also verses are taken out of context. People really need to read the whole gospel/epistle/ etc to get the overall meaning of the book.
Agree. Reading, for instance, all the Psalms in order shows that "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?" that Jesus cries out on the cross is the first line of a song that ends in triumph, and that is followed by "The Lord's my shepherd." Reading all of Song of Songs in one sitting shows that it is, indeed, a song with a pretty chiasmatic structure.
Having verses in isolation is fine, and I'm a big fan of memorizing individual verses from Scripture. But it's not the same as reading everything in context.
"People really need to read the whole gospel/epistle/ etc to get the overall meaning of the book."
An excellent and essential observation. It can be no other way. Double bonus points today!
Thanks Mike, that’s two added to the one I put in a long time ago! lol
By your definition, I am an evangelical although I wrestle with that term. But it is interesting to me what you have discovered in your research, viz. how little devout Catholics (and others) read their Bibles. This is odd to me, because that is the central practice of my Christian faith.
I am not writing to draw attention to myself, but perhaps to exhibit myself as a typical evangelical. Many years ago I adopted a Bible-reading methodology based on Billy Graham's daily practice: Starting in Genesis and Matthew, I read four chapters of the OT and four chapters of the NT (I omit the daily 7 chapters of Psalms as Billy Graham did, I read Psalms in the course of reading). The next day I resume where I left off. And I enjoy reading different versions (except the old King James!). By this method, I read the Bible more than twice through a year. It's fascinating and I learn so much. And I frequent compare verses between different versions, very illuminating. And I am not unique in my church world.
I guess that is why I am dumbfounded when I meet Christians who rarely read their Bibles and have never read it through completely, or only once as some form of box checking ("I did it, I read the Bible all the way through!" type of thing).
If I am a typical evangelical, then this helps to explain the head-shaking that many evangelicals might hold toward, say, Catholics, who are less interested in their Bibles. I have a very devout Catholic friend and we can talk frankly of such things and he simply is not interested in reading the Bible and if he does, it's maybe once a week (I know, a sample of one).
Great post. It exposes the way different Christian denominations (groups) approach the Bible. I guess that is why, in part, my Catholic friend cannot get his head around sola scriptura. :)
Not a Catholic, but it would not surprise me if many Catholics consider the lectionary readings spiritually equivalent to reading the bible. For most of Christian history the average parishioner was either illiterate or didn't have the funds to purchase a bible, so the mass would have been the only realistic access to the scriptures.
This is anecdotal, but I have noticed that the typical evangelical sermon will do a very deep dive on a single scripture, most often from John or Paul's letters, while the average Cathodox service includes a handful of read scriptures from the Psalms, Gospels, epistles, prophets, etc.
Ryan, as a Catholic, I thought, "but wouldn't everyone be doing the lectionary reading, because that's literally reading Scripture, so that adds up to reading the Bible >1x per week....?"
Others have also noted private devotions, like praying Rosary prayers. But this is literally reciting Scripture (Luke 1:26, 42). Do Scripture recitations not count?
I personally think it counts, though I'm not sure how to best get at these kinds of questions on surveys. Undoubtedly the language of religion surveys in the US is a mix of Protestant-coded and secular-coded, probably to ensure a higher completion rate.
In my (mainline) church on a typical Sunday, if I threw a stone at a random pew, it is very likely to hit someone who does not know what the words "lectionary" or "liturgy" mean. But we want those folks participating in these surveys, which unfortunately means using simpler language and more black-and-white questions.
Insightful response. Your thoughts remind me that it is important for believers to understand that the NT was written in Koine Greek, the Greek of the common people, not some scholarly or "academic" form available only to priests and the educated, but meant to be accessible to the regular guy or gal.
I think it would be worth evaluating within Catholics those who grew up in a pre-Vatican II experience vs. a post-Vatican II experience. Is there a change in Bible usage by Roman Catholics along generational lines once the Magisterium opened up Mass and Scripture reading to the vernacular languages?
The people who grew up pre-V2 are over 80 at this point and thus mostly on their way to their eternal reward. The vast majority of current respondents will have grown up post-V2.
Would have been interesting to add the Jews to the mix, as our relation to Hebrew Bible seems quite different, though we have a wide spectrum of attendance at worship. Torah is central to the religion, liturgy is dominated by copy & paste from Biblical sources, so centrality has a high consensus. And Torah plus a section of Prophets is read publicly weekly as part of worship. Self-study seems a little different. It happens widely, across denominations, but we tend not to take the Old Testament that we all got as Bar Mitzvah gifts off the shelf and read from it. What we do instead is seek out commentaries by rabbis or other scholars who have already digested a section of the weekly portion to which they share their insights. It's more like reading op-eds than Cliff Notes, but it's also not reading a primary source that we will hear verbally and follow along in the Books, either in Hebrew or translation, as the reader chants each section.
How well that correlates with attendance is hard to guess. Much of this exposure is passive, the public reading and the rabbi's comments at worship, though many synagogues have classes where the weekly portion is discussed with questions offered to those who attend them. Individual study, likely minimal.
It has always puzzled me why Jews would read the "op-eds" (rabbinic commentaries) more than the primary source. Could you expound on this and explain or guess why this is?
Lots of reasons. First, we do not ignore the primary sources, which are read each Saturday and which they have as part of our religious school curriculum. But for individual ongoing study, the commentaries are much greater in volume, in their spectrum of ideas, and merge better with other parts of education. Our teachers assing us novels and history texts, but our required papers and exams test our interpretations of what we have read. Jewish mental function, embedded in our liturgy, is divided into three parts: da-at or core knowledge, binah or insight, and saichel or good judment. The ability to function this way depends on creating our own opinions of a primary source and appreciating the insights of those who have accumulated greater wisdom. So the commentaries are what we mostly use as learning resources.
Thank you!
It could be because there is no "primary source" as the books in the various bibles are all interpreted, and those interpretations are different depending on a lot of factors. Just my two cents as they say.
But you still have to interpret the interpretations. So does that mean there is no "secondary source" either?
Catholics talk about how the magisterium helps them interpret the Bible... but then talk to 10 Catholics about what the magisterium means and I find there is 12 interpretations of the magisterium's interpretation of the Bible. We just can't get away from interpretation.
That's an excellent point, it really is all interpretations.
As a mainline Protestant pastor CC (DOC) I would guess most of our members fall toward the Catholic bible ownership pattern (family bible, Bible given at baptism, etc) despite us saying we are “people of the book” and “we take the bible seriously, not literally).
Yeah, the mainline never really had Bible quizzing drills and such.
I try my best to respect different traditions and their practices. What sends me into high irritation is an Evangelical Protestant who thinks he is refuting Islam by proof texting passages from the Koran.
I wonder if there might also be a some devotions that Catholics might not count as Bible reading that arguably should. For example, some Catholics read/study the readings for the upcoming Sunday ahead of time. It's something that's highly encouraged at a Newman Center near where I live, and there are groups that meet weekly to discuss the readings. But because those readings are often collected in specialized books like missals or on dedicated websites, I don't think many Catholics would naturally call that "reading the Bible", despite the fact that they're meditating on Scripture.
Two experiences that tie in with the idea that our faiths are oriented in a different manner:
1) As a born and raised Evangelical, it wasn't until I started dating a Catholic that I realized how much scripture they get in their worship services. Perhaps some of the lower individual reading rates is because communal reading holds a greater priority in liturgical traditions.
2) I also didn't appreciate how much church history mattered to Catholics until I attended and event called Theology on Tap with my Catholic friends in university. The speakers cited saints and popes the way that Evangelical speakers cite Bible passages, building arguments from and proof-texting their arguments based on them.
I've come to appreciate the value of communal scripture reading and understanding church history through these and other experiences, even though I still get a lot from my individual study of scripture.
Glad I’m not the only Catholic kid who received a Bible from his Grandma for his First Communion. I still have it to this day, but I can’t say I’ve ever read out of it. As a family we had one BIG Bible that sat on our fire place mantle my entire childhood, that also never got pulled down and read out of.
I’ll give a brief defense of Catholics. I think that as other posters have noted Catholics do other things in their “personal time” with the Lord that Protestants don’t do, so it probably isn’t a totally fair metric. For instance, my Catholic aunts and uncles I would consider to be very much prayer warriors in the sense that I know they spend very much time in personal devotion and prayer-but I don’t honestly think they’ve ever really read through the Bible. I know when I talk to them about Christianity it doesn’t seem like they know it like I have come to know it.
That said, I know that when I converted to evangelicalism as an adult and actually read through the whole Bible for the first time, I actually remember being quite sad just about how little I actually knew about my Christian faith and its history before that endeavor. Reading through the Word has been a huge gift to me and I’ve attempted to tell my Catholic family and friends about how good it is to do, there just isn’t much interest.
I mean, Catholics have to go through the whole "learning Latin" thing before they can get into the readings. 🙃
It would be interesting to know how many folk read the Old Testament together with the New, or, if you will, how many believe that the Bible is, really, just the New Testament, as the Old was superseded by Christ.
Catholics are much less interested in reading the Bible than Evangelicals. This might explain why Catholics are better at gaining institutional power. There are plenty of Catholic academics, but few Evangelicals.
We had a family Bible and maybe a spare. We had two editions of 'Lives of the Saints', but one was grandma's and in German. Individually, we each had a Missal and a rosary.
Thanks Ryan this is good stuff. I'd like to see you do something with the role of 'Tradition" and 'tradition' between Roman Catholics and Protestants. RCs as I understand it, have seen the T as an equal partner with 'reading the Bible' for making disciples.
Ryan, your data raise an important question: What are the implications of these different postures toward Scripture for the shared mission of Catholics and evangelicals?
Both traditions are called to make disciples, yet they approach that mission from substantially different perspectives. Using a military metaphor, it is difficult for allies to win a war when they cannot agree on the mission or how best to accomplish it.
Perhaps the greater danger is not that Christians disagree, but that our differences become so important that we lose sight of the mission we share. Division can become a weakness that is exploited—and we can then rationalize our separate positions rather than honestly asking whether our approach is producing the results Christ commanded.
I explored this question in Christian Unity: Can We Disagree Without Dividing? The central question is simple: Can Christians with important theological differences work together to fulfill the Great Commission?
https://timjclark.substack.com/p/christian-unity-can-we-disagree-without