Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jared P.'s avatar

Speaking as a Catholic, yes we're certainly not "people of the book".

If you hold a Catholic pastor or theologian's feet to the fire, he would have to admit that in Catholic doctrine, it is not strictly necessary for non-clergy to spend ANY time personally reading Scripture — I mean, necessary for one's salvation and sanctification. It's obviously encouraged by the Church nowadays, but only since around the 1890s; there hasn't been as much time for it to permeate Catholic culture.

And personal Scripture reading won't ever occupy quite the same space in a Catholic's heart or mind as it does for a Protestant's because for a Catholic, it's one activity among many that fall under the broader heading of private _devotional_ time.

Ask a Protestant about how much time they spend each week in personal devotions, and the question is practically equivalent to asking how much time they spend reading / studying / meditating on the Bible on their own. But to put the same kind of question fairly to a Catholic, you'd have to ask how much time or how frequently each week they read the Bible OR pray the Rosary OR read some book on the lives of the saints or a Life of Christ or… you get the idea. Because in the minds of most Catholics, all of those activities and more "count" in the same way as "stuff I do by myself to try to get closer to God" i.e. private devotion.

You could say that Catholics may perceive it as "devotion gap" with Protestants, in which we both use Scripture a ton in our public worship, but the big bushy tree of private devotion has been pruned down to only one branch.

Ash's avatar

I’m Catholic and attend weekly. I’d say the Bible is extremely important but I think I read it once last month. I go to adoration twice a week (prayer before the blessed sacrament) pray the rosary 2-3 times a week, plus attend daily mass once a week. I do tend to do more spiritual reading than read the Bible.

My two cents is we just spend our devotional time in other ways. It would be interesting to see a graph of how much time different denominations spend on devotions outside of Sunday attendance. I bet it would be way closer.

44 more comments...

Ready for more?