Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Doctrix Periwinkle's avatar

In the Netherlands, too, the first option in the census survey question about religion is "no religion," and the default setting in Statline, the Statistics Netherlands searchable database, on the religion question sorts respondents into "no religion" versus "something else." You have to go in and fuss with the settings to be able to look at religion by denomination at all. This maybe makes sense in the European Netherlands, where >85% of people list "no religion" as their religion; but in their Caribbean colonies [where I live] it's jarring since >85% of people here self-define as Christian of some variety.

Richard Plotzker's avatar

Often the limitation of surveys is that they tabulate what happened but fall short of explaining why. The collapse of Protestant affiliation in Australia seems more dramatic than in America. Yet it occurred without political alignments that some religion defectors found offensive, without lurid scandals, and without widespread schisms over LGBTQ policies. There does not seem to be as fractious a divide as to who is and is not welcome in sacred space. In the absense of what Americans attribute causes of disaffiliation, the Aussies still have attrition. They probably never had church attendance as a measure of social respectability that large parts of America once had. It raises the question of whether people, there or here, feel pushed out of their religion by adverse perception or whether religious participation just falls short of what Aussies could be doing instead, without some of the animosity that American defectors display.

17 more comments...

Ready for more?