In the Netherlands, too, the first option in the census survey question about religion is "no religion," and the default setting in Statline, the Statistics Netherlands searchable database, on the religion question sorts respondents into "no religion" versus "something else." You have to go in and fuss with the settings to be able to look at religion by denomination at all. This maybe makes sense in the European Netherlands, where >85% of people list "no religion" as their religion; but in their Caribbean colonies [where I live] it's jarring since >85% of people here self-define as Christian of some variety.
Often the limitation of surveys is that they tabulate what happened but fall short of explaining why. The collapse of Protestant affiliation in Australia seems more dramatic than in America. Yet it occurred without political alignments that some religion defectors found offensive, without lurid scandals, and without widespread schisms over LGBTQ policies. There does not seem to be as fractious a divide as to who is and is not welcome in sacred space. In the absense of what Americans attribute causes of disaffiliation, the Aussies still have attrition. They probably never had church attendance as a measure of social respectability that large parts of America once had. It raises the question of whether people, there or here, feel pushed out of their religion by adverse perception or whether religious participation just falls short of what Aussies could be doing instead, without some of the animosity that American defectors display.
You might be able to argue that the various culture wars propped up American Protestantism.
Here, to be a Conservative is practically tantamount to being Christian. The Cold War probably played a major part as well, and furthermore, evangelical Christianity took off in the US while it didn’t in Australia.
I would have been interested in other discrimination questions like, "Should a vegan baker have to make a cake celebrating a boy shooting his first deer?" Or, "Should a Muslim school be allowed to refuse a teacher because he/she is a Christian?"
Another interesting post, but what I found most interesting was the “ballot ordering” effect -- I was completely unaware of this phenomenon. It surely offers insight into the the human psyche!
And the percentage of Australians that "never" go to church (or, I suppose, some other house of worship). What about funerals? Are Australians getting away from the custom of religious funerals?
I would guess that they are. Odd though it might seem, I actually read all the obituaries posted daily in my local paper. Why? I enjoy reading personal histories. And as my community is rather small, I often know these folks or their families, directly or indirectly. What I have noticed is that fewer people have a religious funeral -- in-church or graveside, or even at the funeral home. Instead, the dead are cremated, buried by the family (or ashes strewn somewhere) and a potluck is held in memory of the deceased.
Having just been to a Catholic funeral at a funeral parlor (very obvious when the priest presiding led us in the Lord's Prayer and my family was I swear the only one who forgot to stop early, like the Protestant idiots that we are), I wonder whether the "nones" who attended would have even registered attending this funeral as attending a religious service?
Same with weddings.
It wouldn't surprise me if it's fairly normal to not count the weddings and funerals you've been to outside your own house of worship (if you have one) as "not services", even when clergy preside or they're in a house of worship, and instead count them as social occasions attended to fulfill social obligations, with the religious component incidental.
I agree too, not to mention when it comes to saying the creeds. It isn't like I didn't learn the Apostles Creed as a young child, it's just years of saying the Nicene Creed that are ingrained in my brain.
"And then we have the “something else” category which covers everyone from Latter-day Saints to Buddhists. Here, the Aussies are slightly higher than the Americans at 14% compared to 10%."
An interesting, if not statistically significant (they'd make up less than 0.1% of the Australian population) fact is that Australia shares the distinction, along with Sweden, of having more Mandaeans than any other countries do.
This reflects a working theory I have that the main (religious, but also many, many other ways) difference between America and the other WEIRD countries is thanks to a strange quirk of history, the other WEIRD countries used America as a place to dump their low-church weirdos. Australia, in this sense, looks a lot like what you'd expect a European country to look like but even more so (guessing there's some historical reason COE/Anglicans haven't held up like they did in England, although I think there's a lot of culture/traditional inertia that keep COE going in Albion that didn't make it to Botany Bay).
I've been making this point for a while in comments here. In Australia, the default is Done.. Being religious is like being gay - no problem, but keep it to yourself. Sunday is for sport, not church. "Catholic" remains as a cultural affilation, but no one pays attention to the bishops any more
That's really solidified in the last decade or so.
I do know that the COE has their own prayerbook in New Zealand. It is a beautiful book that reflects the BCP's order of Service but the prayers and other parts are positively stunning. I've read it multiple times and use it as well. Many churches in the US will pull readings from the NZ prayerbook on occasion. My close friend from NZ describes the area where she is from as largely Anglican. She was raised in the Anglican church. She no longer attends because they now live in the States and doesn't candy to the ECUSA. And there you go.
It would be great to make other comparisons between Australia and the US now that the gap in religiosity has been presented, e.g. rates of depression, suicide, drug addiction, charity.
USA has long been an outlier compared to developed countries. Much more religious on many different metrics. Somewhat old graph for importance of religion as function of GDP below. Similar pattern for acceptance of homosexuality according to Pew research in second graph. Then there's a 34 country study in which USA was second to last in acceptance of evolution, a less direct indicator of religiosity.
Interesting that John Anderson/Dorian von Freyhold used the 4 historical measures for their survey and also interesting that they didn't really call out that the growth of their estimate follows (at least visually) the growth of the actual line; they just identified that the final number was different.
I remember reading an article about this question in Australia a while ago about how the question really should be a two-part: "Do you have a religion (yes/no)" Followed by an "If so, which one". This feels like a more neutral way to ask the question but it does mess with the historic data.
In the Netherlands, too, the first option in the census survey question about religion is "no religion," and the default setting in Statline, the Statistics Netherlands searchable database, on the religion question sorts respondents into "no religion" versus "something else." You have to go in and fuss with the settings to be able to look at religion by denomination at all. This maybe makes sense in the European Netherlands, where >85% of people list "no religion" as their religion; but in their Caribbean colonies [where I live] it's jarring since >85% of people here self-define as Christian of some variety.
Makes me want to response ordering experiment in the United States to see how much putting "none" first would shift things.
Often the limitation of surveys is that they tabulate what happened but fall short of explaining why. The collapse of Protestant affiliation in Australia seems more dramatic than in America. Yet it occurred without political alignments that some religion defectors found offensive, without lurid scandals, and without widespread schisms over LGBTQ policies. There does not seem to be as fractious a divide as to who is and is not welcome in sacred space. In the absense of what Americans attribute causes of disaffiliation, the Aussies still have attrition. They probably never had church attendance as a measure of social respectability that large parts of America once had. It raises the question of whether people, there or here, feel pushed out of their religion by adverse perception or whether religious participation just falls short of what Aussies could be doing instead, without some of the animosity that American defectors display.
You might be able to argue that the various culture wars propped up American Protestantism.
Here, to be a Conservative is practically tantamount to being Christian. The Cold War probably played a major part as well, and furthermore, evangelical Christianity took off in the US while it didn’t in Australia.
I would have been interested in other discrimination questions like, "Should a vegan baker have to make a cake celebrating a boy shooting his first deer?" Or, "Should a Muslim school be allowed to refuse a teacher because he/she is a Christian?"
But alas, such questions are not asked.
Another interesting post, but what I found most interesting was the “ballot ordering” effect -- I was completely unaware of this phenomenon. It surely offers insight into the the human psyche!
And the percentage of Australians that "never" go to church (or, I suppose, some other house of worship). What about funerals? Are Australians getting away from the custom of religious funerals?
I would guess that they are. Odd though it might seem, I actually read all the obituaries posted daily in my local paper. Why? I enjoy reading personal histories. And as my community is rather small, I often know these folks or their families, directly or indirectly. What I have noticed is that fewer people have a religious funeral -- in-church or graveside, or even at the funeral home. Instead, the dead are cremated, buried by the family (or ashes strewn somewhere) and a potluck is held in memory of the deceased.
Is dying becoming less sacred?
Less than half of British people wanted a funeral in a survey from a couple years ago.
https://www.theosthinktank.co.uk/in-the-news/2023/11/24/less-than-half-of-us-now-want-a-funeral-says-research
Having just been to a Catholic funeral at a funeral parlor (very obvious when the priest presiding led us in the Lord's Prayer and my family was I swear the only one who forgot to stop early, like the Protestant idiots that we are), I wonder whether the "nones" who attended would have even registered attending this funeral as attending a religious service?
Same with weddings.
It wouldn't surprise me if it's fairly normal to not count the weddings and funerals you've been to outside your own house of worship (if you have one) as "not services", even when clergy preside or they're in a house of worship, and instead count them as social occasions attended to fulfill social obligations, with the religious component incidental.
Very good points!
I agree too, not to mention when it comes to saying the creeds. It isn't like I didn't learn the Apostles Creed as a young child, it's just years of saying the Nicene Creed that are ingrained in my brain.
"And then we have the “something else” category which covers everyone from Latter-day Saints to Buddhists. Here, the Aussies are slightly higher than the Americans at 14% compared to 10%."
An interesting, if not statistically significant (they'd make up less than 0.1% of the Australian population) fact is that Australia shares the distinction, along with Sweden, of having more Mandaeans than any other countries do.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mandaeans
This reflects a working theory I have that the main (religious, but also many, many other ways) difference between America and the other WEIRD countries is thanks to a strange quirk of history, the other WEIRD countries used America as a place to dump their low-church weirdos. Australia, in this sense, looks a lot like what you'd expect a European country to look like but even more so (guessing there's some historical reason COE/Anglicans haven't held up like they did in England, although I think there's a lot of culture/traditional inertia that keep COE going in Albion that didn't make it to Botany Bay).
Would you be willing to break down a comparison with regions of the country?
I don't see a variable for region. I see one for urban vs rural, but that's it.
I've been making this point for a while in comments here. In Australia, the default is Done.. Being religious is like being gay - no problem, but keep it to yourself. Sunday is for sport, not church. "Catholic" remains as a cultural affilation, but no one pays attention to the bishops any more
That's really solidified in the last decade or so.
I do know that the COE has their own prayerbook in New Zealand. It is a beautiful book that reflects the BCP's order of Service but the prayers and other parts are positively stunning. I've read it multiple times and use it as well. Many churches in the US will pull readings from the NZ prayerbook on occasion. My close friend from NZ describes the area where she is from as largely Anglican. She was raised in the Anglican church. She no longer attends because they now live in the States and doesn't candy to the ECUSA. And there you go.
It would be great to make other comparisons between Australia and the US now that the gap in religiosity has been presented, e.g. rates of depression, suicide, drug addiction, charity.
USA has long been an outlier compared to developed countries. Much more religious on many different metrics. Somewhat old graph for importance of religion as function of GDP below. Similar pattern for acceptance of homosexuality according to Pew research in second graph. Then there's a 34 country study in which USA was second to last in acceptance of evolution, a less direct indicator of religiosity.
Religion
https://images.csmonitor.com/csm/2015/03/0316-pew-religion_1.jpg?alias=standard_1200x800nc
Homosexuality
https://www.pewresearch.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/20/2020/06/PG_2020.06.25_Global-Views-Homosexuality_0-03.png?resize=1200,1134
Interesting that John Anderson/Dorian von Freyhold used the 4 historical measures for their survey and also interesting that they didn't really call out that the growth of their estimate follows (at least visually) the growth of the actual line; they just identified that the final number was different.
I remember reading an article about this question in Australia a while ago about how the question really should be a two-part: "Do you have a religion (yes/no)" Followed by an "If so, which one". This feels like a more neutral way to ask the question but it does mess with the historic data.
Edit: I did a bit more digging and while the video posted seems like a genuine neutral project, John Anderson's main site tells a much different message about the less-than-exegetical-nature of this research https://johnanderson.net.au/what-the-census-gets-wrong-about-religion-mark-mccrindle-and-dorian-von-freyhold/